4.4. SR 04-07-2014 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

which the bulls are being used in the bull running events, they are not exempted from coverage under the Act. Discussion To effectuate its animal welfare goals, the AWA must be broadly construed, In re: Lloyd A. Good, Jr., 49 Agric. Dec. 156, n.4 (U.S.D.A. 1990), and USDA has repeatedly done so when it comes to exhibitors. The term exhibitor is not limited to the entities specifically listed in the definition, 9 C.F.R. § 1.1, and the agency has applied it to any person who displays covered animals to the public in any manner and who derives any associated economic benefit, so long as the display of the animals affects interstate commerce. See Good, 49 Agric. Dec. at 163; see also, e.g., In re: Wyoming Department of Parks And Cultural Resources, et al., 67 Agric. Dec. 1071, 1082-84 (U.S.D.A. 2008) (Compensation means any "economic benefit" related to the viewing or display of the animals); and, In re Daniel J. Hill and Montrose Orchards, 67 Agric. Dec. 196, 204 (U.S.D.A. 2008) (USDA has "long held that the use of displayed animals to attract customers to a facility is sufficient to meet the compensation requirement"). Thus, the agency has found the term to encompass an auto parts dealer who maintained exotic animals in his yard, despite the fact that he did not advertise the presence of the animals, and despite the fact that the animals provided him with only de minimis economic benefit. See In re: Ronnie Faircloth & J.R. Auto & Parts, Inc., 52 Agric. Dec. 171 (U.S.D.A. 1993). The exhibition and display of the animals in the bull running events plainly affects commerce and is undertaken for compensation. The events are promoted via the Internet with the bulls being the main attraction, see, e.g., www.thegreatbullrun.com, the public must pay money to the event holders in order to view the animals, and the stampeding event is used to attract people to purchase available concessions." For example, a spectator's ticket for Bull Run costs $10.00 and includes not just the ability to view the actual running of bulls, but also grants "access" to the "day-long festival featuring bands, games, food, beer."I2 The "commerce" requirements of the AWA "are interpreted liberally" and the "acceptance of credit cards for purchases[ ] and the use of internet sites for promotion of [a] business" that exhibits animals are sufficient for the requirements to be met. In re: Daniel J. Hill 67 Agric. Dec. at 203-04; see also In re: Wyoming 11 According to a GBR spokesperson, there are approximately 1,000 people registered to participate in the first scheduled event at a cost of at least $55.00 per person. Meredith Somers, It's no Pamplona, Spain, but the Great Bull Run will thunder into Virginia, THr WASHINGTON Timm, May 14, 2013 (accessible at http://www.washingtontimes.corn/news/2013/may/14/in-the-spanish-spirit-the- great-bull-run-will-thunn. 12 http://www.thegreatbullrun.com/about/ (last accessed May 28, 2013). The "runner" tickets also provide access to the "festival." E.g., http://www.thegreatbullrun.com/events/vrginia-20131 (Last accessed May 28, 2013). 4