Truth in taxation flier starts
<br />a war of words about 'truth'
<br />
<br />By Anthony Lonetree
<br />Star Tribune StaffWriter
<br />
<br /> Truth in Taxation notices hit mail-
<br />boxes statewide beginning next week,
<br />painting worst-case scenarios for
<br />what homeowners could pay in prop-
<br />erty taxes in 2004.
<br /> The final bill for city, county and
<br />school services must still be approved
<br />by each governmental unit in Decem-
<br />ber, but the preliminary notices are
<br />drawing unusual attention in this year
<br />of budget bloodletting.
<br /> The Minnesota Chapter of the Na-
<br />tional Association of Industrial and
<br />Office Properties is spending $50,000
<br />
<br />on a public education campaign that
<br />includes distribution of 200,000
<br />copies of a four-page flier that fingers
<br />local government as the main culprit
<br />for the sharp property tax increases
<br />many communities are projecting for
<br />2004:
<br /> The flier, drawing information
<br />from the Minnesota Taxpayers Associ-
<br />ation's publication, "Understanding
<br />Your Property Taxes," offers a detailed
<br />dissection of the Truth in Taxation no-
<br />tices.
<br />
<br />TAXES continues on A6:
<br />-- State legislator wants notices deliv-
<br /> ered before each fall's election.
<br />
<br />Page A6 · Star Tribune *
<br />
<br />Monday, November 3 · 2003
<br />
<br />TAXES from A1
<br />
<br />House researchers predict
<br />10.9 % increase on average
<br />
<br /> The flier employs a retro
<br />look, with orange colors and
<br />bold headlines. "The state leg-
<br />islature designed the property
<br />tax system, but it's your local
<br />government officials who de-
<br />cide how much you must pay!"
<br />shouts one heading.
<br /> The flashy piece was
<br />panned Friday by League of
<br />
<br />percent statewide.
<br /> Sbme cities, counties and
<br />schools have made preliminary
<br />moves to raise taxes by double-
<br />digit percentages, but Carlson,
<br />of the League of Minnesota Cit-
<br />ies, said there had been little in
<br />the way of street-level talk
<br />about taxes, a situation he said
<br />could change with next week's
<br />
<br />Tax
<br />
<br />truths
<br />
<br />By early November, Minnesota property owners should receive Truth in
<br />Taxation notices outlining their proposed 2004 taxes and how taxpayers
<br />can participate in local government deliberations on taxes and spending.
<br />Here's a guide to the information contained in the statements.
<br />
<br />Minnesota Cities officials.
<br /> What the flier "casually ig-
<br />nores,'' said Gary Carlson, the
<br />league's legislative director, is
<br />the fact that the Legislature
<br />and Gov. Tim Pawlenty cut
<br />$170 million in state aid to cit-
<br />ies.
<br /> "It's a disservice," he said.
<br />
<br />Trouble ahead
<br /> For about 20 years, counties
<br />have been required to calculate
<br />
<br />delivery of tax notices.
<br /> Kaye Rakow, state public
<br />policy director for the Industri-
<br />al and Offices Properties
<br />group, hopes so. She acknowl-
<br />edged there have been aid cuts
<br />but said that the tax changes
<br />enacted by the 2001 Legislature
<br />made clear through the state's
<br />takeover of much of basic-edu-
<br />cation funding that local prop-
<br />erty taxes were just that local.
<br /> "You have to go there for the
<br />
<br />Basic information about pro~rty tax
<br />system and the proposed property
<br />taxes described below.
<br />
<br />Your Proposed Property Tax for 2004
<br />
<br />potential tax bills for each par-
<br />cel within their jurisdiction.
<br />The projections are based in
<br />part on the proposed "maxi-
<br />mum" levies set by cities,
<br />counties and school districts,
<br />numbers that often are low-
<br />ered when the bodies take final
<br />action on tax plans in Decem-
<br />ber.
<br /> The tax notices also specify
<br />dates for each government en-
<br />tity's troth in taxation hearing,
<br />but rarely have those events
<br />generated much excitement.
<br /> This year, with the state
<br />Legislature slashing budgets
<br />and shifting the costs of some
<br />programs to local govern-
<br />ments, property owners have
<br />been put on notice that a
<br />healthy chunk of the revenue-
<br />raising side of budget-balanc-
<br />ing will fall to them.
<br /> The Minnesota House's
<br />nonpartisan research depart-
<br />ment estimated this summer
<br />that property taxes next year
<br />would rise an average of 10.9
<br />
<br />Property lOCation .......
<br /> and owners
<br />responsible for making the tax
<br />payment.
<br />
<br />place to start," she said. ~~"x ~,~ 1,104.114
<br />
<br /> In past years, the prelimi-
<br />nary tax statements were re-
<br />quired to include two columns
<br /> ng o mucho a opo ed I
<br />t~ ~crease ~ or decrease --
<br />was due to loc~ government I ~
<br />spending and how much re- ~l~,on of tax ~
<br />s~ted &om cuts ~ state ~d or payments among ~
<br />o~er factors, jur sd ct ons. ~
<br />The req~ement, however, II ~~g~_ ..
<br />was removed q~edy ~is ye~
<br />
<br />"T~s wo~d have been ~e ~ I~~~
<br />year" for that kind of detail,
<br />C~ison s~d. me and place where
<br /> hear ngs on 2004 proposed k [ ~ffi ~ ~ I .; ....
<br />But Ron Abrms, R-M~ne- ~ili ~e-~l~:-'
<br /> . ~ ~ ~ mom ~mormm~on:
<br /> prope~ taxes will be held
<br />to~a, ch~rm~ of ~e M~e- ,~ wnere to call for more
<br />sota House T~ Committee, information about your
<br />
<br />I
<br />
<br />fore each fall's general election.
<br />More citizens need to get in-
<br />volved in the tax debate, said
<br />Rep. Paul Marquart, DFL-Dil-
<br />worth. His initiative to move
<br />
<br />proposed tax bill.
<br />
<br />and a host of background play-
<br />ers, from Carlson to Lynn Reed,
<br />executive director of the Min-
<br />nesota Taxpayers Association,
<br />said there was a logical reason
<br />for the move: Counties always
<br />had trouble with the calcula-
<br />tions.
<br />
<br />zenry.
<br /> Its Troth in Taxation notice
<br />will include a link to a Web
<br />page answering key property-
<br />tax questions, said Chris Samu-
<br />
<br />Source: Minnesota Taxpayers Association
<br />
<br /> Next year a state legislator
<br />plans to renew his push for leg-
<br />islation requiting the tax-warn-
<br />ing notices to be delivered be-
<br />
<br />-- Market value of the property for
<br /> the previous and current tax
<br /> years. It is too late to challenge
<br /> these values, which are
<br /> determined by the county
<br /> assessor and used to calculate
<br /> the proposed tax bill.
<br />
<br />up the tax-notice calendar did
<br />not survive House-Senate ne-
<br />gotiations this year.
<br /> For Ramsey County, the fo-
<br />cus now is to educate the citi-
<br />
<br />el, manager of local govern-
<br />ment policy and research.
<br /> The site's not up yet, but the
<br />questions have a familiar ring.
<br /> "Why are notices sent out
<br />
<br />$ 1,212.60
<br />
<br />6t8,00
<br />
<br />Proposed tax and previous year tax
<br />'for all local governments, plus a
<br />calculation of the percent change
<br />for the property's total proposed tax
<br />compared to last year.
<br />
<br />What's missing?
<br />Until this year, statements also
<br />included two middle columns
<br />seeking to show how much of
<br />any tax increase or decrease
<br />was due to changes in local-
<br />government spending and how
<br />much was due to changes in the
<br />propero/s market value, changes
<br />in state aid and other factors.
<br />The state Legislature voted this
<br />year to no longer require that
<br />information.
<br />
<br />Mark Boswell/Star Tribune
<br />
<br />after elections?" says one.
<br /> "What happened to the two
<br />columns?" reads another.
<br />
<br />To read the Industrial and OjJgt. e
<br />Properties group flier online, go to
<br />http://unvw, naiopmn, org/
<br />
<br />Anthony Lonetree is at
<br />alonetree@startribune, com.
<br />
<br />
<br />
|